Bose Portable: quality at a price
The Bose SoundDock Portable looks great and performs well, but SEAN BACHER finds the price doesn't justify the better sound quality.
Since its inception in 1964, American-based audio specialist, Bose, has built a name synonymous with quality. Along with that, it has built a reputation of being more expensive than many of its competitors, but not deterring many from making the expensive investment. The mini sound speakers are quite often used in boardrooms, bars and restaurants around the world and offer crystal-clear sound that rivals most speakers twice their size.
Testament to the Bose sound quality is that it is used as the standard audio system in luxury cars like Audi, BMW and Mercedes, and according to Wikipedia, Bose products can be found in many military and NASA applications.
It is therefore not surprising to find Bose accessories compatible with smartphones. One example is the Bose SoundDock Portable. A portable docking station for iPhones and iPods that works off rechargeable batteries.
We put the Bose SoundDock Portable through the Gadget Five Question User.
1. Ease of use (including set-up)
Although the Bose SoundDock Portable, comes with instructions, they are not needed and in most cases, it will be ready to operate the minute it is removed from the box and an iPhone or iPod is plugged into it.
If the batteries on either the phone or docking station are flat though, the charger needs to be plugged into it before it can be used. You don't need to wait for the batteries to charge fully before using it.
Bose has taken the minimalist approach with the SoundDock as on the right are two touch-sensitive Volume buttons and that's it. No Power or other controls. The included remote is also very easy to use. It uses standard Play, Pause, Volume and Skip buttons, all well labelled.
The front of the docking station is made up of a silver grill, below which is the retractable iPhone dock. Although the casing around the connector is designed to accommodate an iPhone’s protective skin, it was not big enough to for the bumper I had on my phone, which meant I had to take the phone out of the case every time I wanted to plug it in.
On the plus side though, unlike many other portable docking stations, the Bose will charge a docked phone – even if it is just running off battery power.
The Bose SoundDock Portable’s ease of use along with its elegant design cannot be faulted. But its dock connector counts against it.
2. General performance
The two front facing speakers offer crisp sounds and when the volume is cranked up all the way the SoundDock does not distort at all and is deafeningly loud.
At the rear is 3.5mm jack, allowing you to connect non-Apple phones, MP3 players and other audio equipment.
According to Bose, the 1 900mAh rechargeable battery pack will offer up to three hours of music at a maximum volume – a different approach to rating battery life as most other vendors rate operating times at “typical listening volumes”. I have been using the SoundDock on and off and not at full tilt for the past week without having to plug the mains adapter in yet.
This is however a good thing. Although the Bose SoundDock Portable is elegant and well made, Bose didn’t pay to much attention to the adaptor. It is a bit bigger than two cellphone chargers placed next to each other. It monopolises all the other electrical outlets, when plugged into the wall, meaning you need a dedicated plug for when you want to charge the battery.
The Bose SoundDock Portable provides a beautiful sound, its battery life is great, but the giant-sized charger is a complete let down.
3. Does it add value to your life?
Unlike many docking stations that are designed for bedside listening, the Bose SoundDock Portable is powerful enough to offer good sound in an average sized dining room or lounge.
Weighing in at just under three kilograms, it is not the lightest of them all, but the rear, recessed-handle makes carrying it fairly easy. (A carry bag is available as an optional extra.) Overall, it is a nice addition for a picnic or where an electrical outlet is not available.
Sound docks have been around for years, and although the SoundDock offers superior sound, it offers nothing in the way of innovation. In fact, the lack of Bluetooth or any wireless connectivity for that matter is limiting.
5. Value for money
Much like the die-hard Apple Mac fans that will spend more on a product that performs much the same as cheaper alternatives, you get the same in the audio/visual world.
This becomes especially clear when reading the various reviews posted on the Internet. Reviewers either dislike the Bose SoundDock Portable due to it price, while others like it, saying the sound quality justifies the price.
But at R5 000 for a docking station I would have to agree with the former reviewers. R5 000 is ridiculously overpriced, even though it offers superior sound.
There is no faulting the Bose SoundDock Portable in terms of elegance and sound, but its clunky charger and high price are complete turnoffs.
Total score: 71%
* Follow Sean on Twitter on @seanbacher